Hand Tossed New York Style Pizza
Our dough is made daily and allowed to rest before being hand tossed into one of your favorite pies. Grab a slice today.
Order Now
It’s All About The Sauce
Vitolli’s makes all of our sauces from scratch. In fact, you can find Vitolli’s Marinara and Creamy Italian dressing at local supermarkets throughout Baldwin County.

Check out Vitolli's House Products for more info.
Order Now
Previous slide
Next slide

About Us

How it Started

Vitolli’s Pizzeria and Italian Eatery began in Robertsdale, Alabama in 2007 by Mark and Mindy Nicholson. Both were running another pizzeria in Gulf Shores prior to that when hurricane Ivan demolished that location. They salvaged what they could, gathered their belongings and settled in Robertsdale. Since then Vitolli’s has been pleasing guests, rooting itself within the community and becoming a hometown favorite. In 2023, the Rieves family purchased the restaurant, continuing the tradition of locally owned and family operated. So from our family to yours, please join us for your next meal.

A Reputation In Robertsdale For Delicious Dishes

We’ve built a reputation in Robertsdale and throughout the Gulf Coast for delicious New York style pizza and homestyle pasta dishes. We always offer friendly service and a warm, inviting atmosphere. We’re proud to offer a delicious dining option for folks throughout Baldwin County.

Our Strength

Why We Are The Best ?

A Slice for Everyone

Try our gourmet pizzas or create your own favorite. We also serve by the slice.

Fresh Ingredients

Local veggies delivered every other day. Our dough and sauces are made from scratch.

A Hometown Tradition

Serving Robertsdale and surrounding areas since 2007. We gotta be doing something right.

Local, Family Owned And Operated

As a locally owned, family-operated business that started in 2007, we’re proud to support the community in which we’re located. From being actively involved in community events through our partners and locally sourcing the freshest ingredients, we strive to see our communities thrive. We’re happy to host your next special event or family get-together. Our restaurant offers dine-in and pick-up services and we’ll ensure you love every bite. Our dough is made from a special recipe, always fresh, never frozen and our sauces are all homemade. When it comes to delicious pizza, pasta, subs and more, there’s no better choice than Vitolli’s Pizzeria and Italian Eatery. Call or visit us today to see what makes us special, sets us apart from the rest, and why our guests keep coming back!

Scroll to Top